So last week I made two different brands of brownie mix and this week, you guessed it…cupcakes! Technically it’s cake mix that I am comparing this week just made into cupcake form. In my mind cupcakes are way better than cake Little individual cups of yummy goodness. Again, its Betty Crocker Chocolate Cake Mix compared to Arrowhead Mill’s Vanilla Cake Mix. I’ve made the Betty Crocker ones before and loved them and I’ll be making the Arrowhead Mill’s ones for the first time. The Arrowhead Mill’s mix was in the batch of mixes one of my co-workers brought me a few weeks ago.
I love cupcakes, and I seek them out. Over the Christmas I went to New Jersey, New York and Massachusetts to visit Bryan and our families. On one of our little adventures to NYC we got the chance to go to BabyCakes! Now those are some tasty cupcakes!! Wow. I think I spent almost $40.00 on cupcakes, why?? Not because of the price (well sort of) but because I couldn’t decide which ones to buy. Sooo Bryan and I picked a few and got two of each so we could both try them, because I don’t share cupcakes very well. I think we ended up with the Vanilla, Chocolate and Brownie cupcakes. All of which were AMAZING but I think the brownie ones were our favorite. – I can’t wait to go back there again!
When Bryan came to visit me in February we took a weekend trip up to San Francisco. We kept seeing this van that says “Kara’s Cupcakes” on the side and I obviously kept trying to figure out where they were located. On our last night there, we are heading to go pick up the car at our hotel and he saw there store and Bryan, being the amazing boyfriend that he is, went in just to see if they offered gluten free cupcakes. To both of our surprise they did! But, sadly they were sold out. I was a little crushed until he told me that they had another store, and if I knew what flavor I wanted they would call over to see if they could hold two for us. Thankfully the other store had some left, we got there right before they closed and the best part was, they were two blocks from out hotel! ha ha. While at the store I started chatting with the girl behind the counter and to my surprise they started with Erin from BabyCakes NYC’s recipe and adapted it to make it their own…no wonder why they were so good and we loved them so much. We were patient enough to not eat them until we got home (about 2.5 hours) before digging into our little gems. Again, the cupcakes were AMAZING!!
This summer when I move I am hoping to try some cupcakes from Tu-Lu’s Gluten Free Bakery (also in NYC). If anyone has tried them, I would love to hear your thoughts
So here are the results of this weeks battle of the cupcakes (both sets of cupcakes will have the same frosting-yes its gluten free!!):
Betty Crocker Chocolate Cupcakes with Betty Crocker Rich and Creamy Rainbow Chip Frosting
Arrowhead Mills Vanilla Cupcakes with Betty Crocker Rich and Creamy Rainbow Chip Frosting
Betty Crocker - I followed the directions on the back of the package and cooked it according to the time given.
Moist, tasty, chocolaty. Taste and texture of a “real” cupcake. As with the brownie mix from Betty Crocker you can’t tell the difference from the gluten containing cupcakes.
Arrowhead Mills – I followed the directions on the back of the package and cooked it according to the time given.
Moist, tasty vanillay. The taste was pretty good, however the texture was a bit different. They were a little grainy, almost like it has a little bit of a crunchy texture, more like cornmeal-ish texture to it. Over all they were still very good, I really enjoyed them.
Now I have a little more than two dozen cupcakes and I am only one person so as with the majority of things I bake these will be coming to work with me tomorrow. My co-workers have become my “test kitchen” over the past two years.
And the winner is….
I have to say that the winner of this one has got to be the Betty Crocker mix, but probably only because of the texture of the Arrowhead Mills. You really can’t tell that these and the frosting are gluten free. Betty Crocker has done very well with these mixes, I am highly impressed.
Now to wash these down with a nice big glass of soy milk!!